HaShem, Can You Hear Us?Mishkan Research Institute

How the research is done

The method, the sources, and the order they are read in. None of this is a finding. It is how a reading is tested before it is said out loud.

The question

The Torah describes a structure that has not stood since the First Temple was built, and it describes it the way a builder would: the material of each part, the measurement of each part, the count of the parts, and the way they fasten to one another.

The question asked here is the engineer's question rather than the artist's. Not what did it look like, but what does the text require. Those are two different questions and they do not always give the same answer.

The sources, and only these

Tanakh in the masoretic text. Talmud Bavli and Yerushalmi. Midrash. The Rishonim and the Acharonim on the verses themselves. The halachic literature. The kabbalistic classics, including Sefer Yetzirah and the Zohar.

Nothing outside that body is cited as evidence. Not a modern scholarly reconstruction, not an archaeological parallel, not a comparative study, not anything from outside the tradition.

A reconstruction printed in a modern edition is not a source. It is somebody's reading, it is often a good one, and it is still not the text. Where this work differs from a familiar modern reconstruction it says so, names it, and gives the verse and the commentator it is reading instead.

The order they are read in

The verse first, in its own words, with what it does and does not say.

Then the commentators who read that verse, in the order they wrote.

Then the halachic and midrashic material that turns on it.

A measurement that no verse gives is reported as a measurement that no verse gives. Where it is derived, the derivation is shown and named as a derivation.

The test, and the register of what failed

A reading is worth something only if it could have come out the other way. So each one is put to the text and to the arithmetic, and the result is recorded either way.

The Institute keeps a register of the readings that did not survive that test, including ones that were attractive and ones that had already been written up. They are marked closed and they stay in the file, because a body of work with no negative results in it is not a body of work.

Where the sources themselves disagree, the disagreement is reported as a disagreement and the verdict is left open. Nothing here is a halachic ruling.

What is published

The classes and the source sheets are free and are meant to be shared whole.

Some of the work is finished and not yet published. When it is published it will carry its sources, so that anybody can take it apart.

Who is behind this Send me the sheet